• Home
  • About
  • Exercise at Home
    • 10-Day Challenge
  • Blog
  • Workshops
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Videos
    • Posters
Performance RedefinedPerformance Redefined
  • Home
  • About
  • Exercise at Home
    • 10-Day Challenge
  • Blog
  • Workshops
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Videos
    • Posters
Emphasize Movement to Make Exercise Matter!

Emphasize Movement to Make Exercise Matter!

July 6, 2017 Articles

Placing an emphasis on how we move move while exercising can be critical to facilitating behavioral changes beyond the gym environment. For physically active populations and occupational athletes such as firefighters, soldiers and police officers this implies that exercise programs designed with a movement focus could have a direct impact on their safety and effectiveness by engraining desirable movement patterns that transfer to job and/or life-relevant tasks. This post provides a brief summary of the 2015 study conducted by Frost, DM, Beach, TAC, Callaghan, JP, and McGill, SM. Exercise-based performance enhancement and injury prevention for firefighters: Contrasting the fitness- and movement related adaptations to two training methodologies. J Strength Cond Res 29(9): 2441–2459, 2015.

STUDY BACKGROUND

Exercise can be an amazing tool. It can be used to make difficult tasks easier and more enjoyable; it can be used to prevent musculoskeletal injuries and pain; and it can allow us to perform at levels that far exceed any expectations that we might have…that is, if there is an emphasis on the transfer to non-exercise related tasks. To improve the transfer of training it has been suggested that exercises be prescribed to replicate the tasks of interest, which for firefighters, would imply that various high-risk, physically demanding job-tasks be simulated in a gym setting. Though such an approach may seem logical, it is very unlikely to afford the most favorable adaptations – enhancing capacity to match the demands of one’s job (or life) cannot be accomplished by simply recommending a particular exercise, intensity or training volume. It is not about the exercise. Feedback and coaching are essential as is an appreciation for movement to guarantee that the motion strategies being used are safe, effective and suited to the training objectives. It is this type of training that may afford the best possible opportunity to change an individual’s habitual way of performing.

STUDY DESIGN

Fifty-two incumbent firefighters completed a comprehensive fitness test, the Functional Movement Screen (FMS) and a laboratory-based biomechanical assessment wherein they were asked to perform five fundamental movement patterns (i.e. squat, lunge, push, pull and lift) with varying loads and speeds. Following their baseline tests, individuals were assigned to one of three groups: 1) movement–centered intervention, 2) fitness-centered intervention, or 3) control. Participants in the intervention groups attended three 1.5-hour coach-administered training sessions each week for 12 weeks, after which time they were reevaluated with the original battery of tests.

Throughout the investigation the coaches were blind to the testing protocols and the researchers were removed from training. The firefighters were not privy to the study objectives nor were they given any coaching or feedback regarding their performance on the FMS or any lab-based test. In this way, changes in their habitual movement patterns could be evaluated. All movement patterns were characterized with 7 or 8 variables; however, only changes to “key features” that have been previously linked to injury (i.e. spine and frontal plane knee motion) are presented.

KEY FINDINGS

Following twelve weeks of training, both intervention groups exhibited substantial changes in body composition, aerobic capacity, muscular strength and endurance, and upper and lower body power. However, only those participants in the movement-centered group demonstrated a positive adaptation to each lab-based transfer task – their habitual movement patterns changed. In each instance, participants exhibited less aberrant motion with one or more of the “key features” that have been previously linked to injury: spine flexion while lifting and lunging, lateral bend and twist while lunging, pushing and pulling, and frontal plane knee motion while squatting. The firefighters who participated in the fitness-centered intervention did exhibit an improved ability to resist spine motion in the lateral bend and twist directions while lunging, pushing and pulling; however, these changes were noted along with increased spine flexion and frontal plane knee motion while squatting, lunging, pushing and pulling.

Important to note was that the firefighters’ adaptations to training were also task specific. That is, had only the lifting tasks, for example, been used as transfer tests our interpretation of the results would be dramatically different. The fitness-centered group did not exhibit any observable changes (positive or negative) post-training, and thus we would have failed see how poorly or how well they did adapt to select tasks. Likewise, using the FMS to interpret the effectiveness of training would have skewed the results by masking the substantial improvements observed amongst firefighters who participated in the movement-centered training. Despite demonstrating a superior ability to resist aberrant motion, and thus move in a more controlled manner, there were no changes noted in the post-training FMS scores of the movement-trained firefighters.

IMPLICATIONS

1. Exercise can be used to change an individual’s habitual movement patterns

Periodized exercise programs and well-designed feedback protocols work – they can (and should) be used to improve capacity. Whether targeting fitness (e.g. strength) on a specific test or the kinematics of a task, most interventions are able to elicit changes in the direction hypothesized by the researchers/coaches to be of benefit. For example, scientists have been able to reduce the knee abduction moment in females performing a drop jump (Myer et al, 2007), alleviate patellofemoral pain in runners (Noehren et al, 2010), lower spinal moments during lifting (Kernozek et al, 2006) and improve performance in the clean (Rucci and Tomporowski, 2010) and snatch (Winchester et al, 2009). However, there had been little evidence to suggest that an exercise-based intervention could significantly alter the movement patterns used to perform a transfer task, let alone five distinct patterns of varying demands. Developing coordination (ultimately what we are trying to do) is not a simple process given that the adaptations demonstrated by each individual are influenced by their prior experience, inherent aptitudes and personal objectives, not to mention the characteristics of each task being learned. The fact that the movement-trained firefighters demonstrated a superior ability post-training to resist spine and frontal plane knee motion across all lab-based tests provides a tremendous framework with which to approach the prevention of future musculoskeletal injury.

2. Placing an emphasis on fitness alone may increase one’s risk of injury

Being physically fit, in the traditional sense, may not equate to being physically prepared for one’s job (or life). Fitness is essential, particularly for fire fighters (or soldiers, police officers, etc), but alone it is not sufficient to ensure peak performance and long-term durability. It simply reflects an individual’s potential. For example, poor torso extensor endurance has been cited as a marker for future low-back troubles in men (Beiring-Sorensen, 1984), although it is not one of the commonly described mechanisms of low-back injury (e.g. spine posture) (Callaghan and McGill, 2001). A possible explanation is that superior endurance provides the opportunity to maintain spine-sparing postures for extended periods of time by delaying the onset of fatigue. But, if individuals cannot, or choose not to adopt these postures for any number of reasons, muscular endurance becomes secondary and will have little bearing on the risk of injury. Great fitness in the presence of poor movement, or great movement in the presence of poor fitness, will limit performance and increase one’s chances of sustaining a musculoskeletal injury. Firefighters in the fitness-centered group exhibited tremendous improvements in aerobic capacity, strength, endurance and power, but may have actually increased their risk of future injury given their propensity to increase spine flexion and frontal plane knee motion when performing each of the transfer tasks.

3. An individual’s movement patterns do not simply reflect their ability to perform

The degree to which a movement strategy is altered in response to an increased/decreased task demand will depend on factors such as perception of risk, awareness, coordination, strength, endurance and mobility. Speculating as to the exact reason why a pattern is changed would therefore be very difficult, particularly given the lack of evidence to support a homogeneous response. Faced with the task of picking up a pencil off the floor, highly astute, physically capable firefighters may not choose to adopt the same strategy that they would to lift a heavy piece of equipment, if the perception of the pencil task was such that it could not cause harm. On the other hand, highly astute firefighters with poor fitness may exhibit similar patterns for both tasks because they lack the strength necessary to perform the heavy lift in such as manner that would be viewed as “safe” or “good”; the demands of the task exceed their capacity to perform in a safe and effective manner. Whole-body movement screens are frequently used to assess one’s ability to perform various general patterns (e.g. squat, lunge), yet little consideration is ever given to the possibility that a task’s demands may influence the way an individual moves. Screens typically comprise bodyweight patterns and individuals are instructed to perform in a slow, controlled manner, irrespective of the population being tested, the most commonly cited injuries (location and type) amongst this population, or the long-term rationale behind the evaluation.

Recent Articles

  • Keys to implementing healthy workplace initiatives The overall health and performance benefits of engaging in regular...
    Read More
  • Firefighter fitness MUST be prioritized beyond the training academy! Although the International Association of Fire Fighters’ (IAFF) and Fire...
    Read More
  • FMS scores improve when told the grading criteria Deficits in joint mobility and/or stability could certainly impact individuals’...
    Read More

Instagram

The magnitude of an external load is only one fact The magnitude of an external load is only one factor that will influence the demand of an exercise.

The type, shape, distribution, and position of load can dramatically alter the demands on the body, the potential benefits of the exercise, and the physical challenge.

For example, 50 lbs is not simply 50 lbs if alternating between a weight vest and kettlebell, using symmetrical and asymmetrical loading patterns, or changing the height at which a load is held.

Be creative, leverage the unique benefits of many 'tools' and build the physical literacy to handle the demands of many environments.

One leg RDL x 6 (kettlebell in opposite hand)
Rear foot elevated split squat x 6 (kettlebell in opposite hand) x 6
2 Rounds

One leg RDL x 6 (weight vest)
Rear foot elevated split squat x 6 (weight vest) x 6
2 Rounds

One leg RDL x 6 (kettlebell in same hand + vest)
Rear foot elevated split squat x 6 (kettlebell in same hand + vest) x 6
2 Rounds

#performanceredefined #exercisesaretools #exercisechallenge #fitnessprinciples #exercisebiomechanics #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitntess #5minutesoffun #fittothrive
Despite having an appreciation for the wide range Despite having an appreciation for the wide range of benefits that come from regular exercise, many people are not meeting the @who weekly physical activity recommendations.

As such, education that further highlights the benefits of exercise and a series of diverse exercise options may not address the inactivity crisis.

Behavioral solutions that address the underlying reasons why someone is not as active as they could (or should) be must be explored.

Identify the WHY before the WHAT to inform the selection of more relevant solutions that can create meaningful and lasting changes.

Join us in our pursuit to help more people be more active more often!

#beactive #bemoreactive #behaviorchange #moreactive #exerciserecommendations #firefighterfitness #moreactivemoreoften #performanceredefined #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #fittothrive
When it comes to designing exercise programs, cont When it comes to designing exercise programs, context always matters. There are few things that should ‘never’ be done, and likely fewer that are ‘always’ true.

Consider the performer(s), objective(s), environment, etc. and be willing explore new ideas because there are always multiple ways to achieve the same outcome.

One arm snatch x 4 each arm
Pull-up x 2
5 Rounds

One arm bench press x 6 each arm
Asymmetrical back lunge x 6 each leg
3 Rounds

One arm snatch x 4 each arm
Pull-up x 2
5 Rounds

#performanceredefined #beactive #hotelexercise #hyattfitness #physicalliteracy #makeexercisematter #knowyourwhy #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #5minutesoffun #fittothrive
Many people get hurt when the demands of the activ Many people get hurt when the demands of the activities they perform exceed their capacity to move in a safe and effective manner.

This implies that without sufficient fitness we could be forced to perform in a way that elevates our risk of getting hurt.

Exercise can undoubtedly help with the prevention of injuries, but it if the injuries typically incurred by a particular population (such as fire fighters) stem from high demand activities, increasing fitness may need to be emphasized to reduce the risk of getting hurt.

To move well within any context implies that sufficient fitness is present - preventing injuries and improving performance really are two sides of the same coin.

#performanceredefined #injuryprevention #fitnessmatters #demandscapacity #movementmatters #firefighterfitness #preventionisperformance #iaffwfi 
#iaffpeerfitness #fittothrive
If you find yourself with limited time, space or e If you find yourself with limited time, space or equipment, try using a workout ‘complex’.

Complexes involve a series of exercises performed in succession with the same equipment, same load, and same space and can be used to meet a range of objectives.

Right arm snatch x 2
Right arm squat to press x 3
Right arm back to front lunge x 4
Right arm squat to press x 3
Right arm snatch x 2

Don't put the load down. Repeat with left arm.

Perform as many rounds as possible in 20 minutes.

#exercisechallenge #workoutcomplex #beactive #makeexercisefun #performanceredefined #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #5minutesoffun #fittothrive
Grace starts with gratitude. Be kind. Be honest Grace starts with gratitude.

Be kind.
Be honest.
Be thoughtful.
Be gracious.
Be supportive.
Be positive.
Be sincere.
Be present.

We are better together.

#mindset #gratitude #thankful #relationships #connection #kindness #wellness #iaffwfi #performanceredefined #fittothrive
While there are an infinite number of ways to desi While there are an infinite number of ways to design workouts, it may be helpful to consider the positions (ranges of motion), motions (movement solutions) and fitness characteristics (intensity and time) that will be targeted prior to choosing exercises.

Will specific joint ranges of motion be emphasized?

Will specific movement patterns be encouraged?

Will specific fitness attributes be challenged?

Exercises are simply tools to achieve the intended benefit. Start with WHY and then choose WHAT will be used to make it happen.

Example Objective: Challenge active shoulder mobility and control of scapular motion in vertical and horizontal plane with a moderate load.

Pull-up x 3
Overhead squat x 6
Right-arm hanging press x 9
Pull-up x 3
Overhead squat x 6
Left-arm hanging press x 9

3 Rounds

#makeexercisematter #physicalliteracy #activemobility #movementpatterns #7keyfeatures #exerciseprogramdesign #firefighterfitness #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #performanceredefined #5minutesoffun #fittothrive
Progress reflects the cumulative influence of seve Progress reflects the cumulative influence of several small actionable steps.

The choices we make and the actions we take every day will shape our behaviors and the extent to which we grow in the long term.

In the moment it can be challenging to see progress being made, perhaps because it is the small seemingly insignificant steps made consistently that produce big results.

Failing is ok if we get back up and try again. It's how we learn.

We are all beginners first.

#growth #growthmindset #smallsteps #smallstepbigchange #takeaction #makethingshappen #mindset #progress #goalsetting #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness 
#learntofail #performanceredefined #fittothrive
Learning to move for work, life and play is not ab Learning to move for work, life and play is not about perfecting any specific exercise technique.

In some instances, there will be certain movement characteristics that could or should be emphasized, but variability can help to facilitate learning.

Challenge yourself, use a range of demands, and explore multiple movement solutions when you have the opportunity to do so.

Air squat x 20s ON + 10s OFF (6 Rounds)
Front squat x 20s ON + 10s OFF (6 Rounds)
Squat to press x 20s ON + 10s OFF (6 Rounds)
Front squat x 20s ON + 10s OFF (6 Rounds)
Air squat x 20s ON + 10s OFF (6 Rounds)

Rest 2 minutes between each exercise.

Monitor progress by tracking the fewest reps performed in any round of Air squats.

#challenge #exercisechallenge #movementvariability #physicalliteracy #learntomove #worklifeplay #fordutyforlife #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #5minutesoffun #performanceredefiined #fittothrive

Send Us a Message!

Send us an email and we'll get back to you ASAP.

Send Message

Contact Info

  • info@performanceredefined.ca

F2T Refund Policies

The magnitude of an external load is only one fact The magnitude of an external load is only one factor that will influence the demand of an exercise.

The type, shape, distribution, and position of load can dramatically alter the demands on the body, the potential benefits of the exercise, and the physical challenge.

For example, 50 lbs is not simply 50 lbs if alternating between a weight vest and kettlebell, using symmetrical and asymmetrical loading patterns, or changing the height at which a load is held.

Be creative, leverage the unique benefits of many 'tools' and build the physical literacy to handle the demands of many environments.

One leg RDL x 6 (kettlebell in opposite hand)
Rear foot elevated split squat x 6 (kettlebell in opposite hand) x 6
2 Rounds

One leg RDL x 6 (weight vest)
Rear foot elevated split squat x 6 (weight vest) x 6
2 Rounds

One leg RDL x 6 (kettlebell in same hand + vest)
Rear foot elevated split squat x 6 (kettlebell in same hand + vest) x 6
2 Rounds

#performanceredefined #exercisesaretools #exercisechallenge #fitnessprinciples #exercisebiomechanics #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitntess #5minutesoffun #fittothrive
Despite having an appreciation for the wide range Despite having an appreciation for the wide range of benefits that come from regular exercise, many people are not meeting the @who weekly physical activity recommendations.

As such, education that further highlights the benefits of exercise and a series of diverse exercise options may not address the inactivity crisis.

Behavioral solutions that address the underlying reasons why someone is not as active as they could (or should) be must be explored.

Identify the WHY before the WHAT to inform the selection of more relevant solutions that can create meaningful and lasting changes.

Join us in our pursuit to help more people be more active more often!

#beactive #bemoreactive #behaviorchange #moreactive #exerciserecommendations #firefighterfitness #moreactivemoreoften #performanceredefined #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #fittothrive
When it comes to designing exercise programs, cont When it comes to designing exercise programs, context always matters. There are few things that should ‘never’ be done, and likely fewer that are ‘always’ true.

Consider the performer(s), objective(s), environment, etc. and be willing explore new ideas because there are always multiple ways to achieve the same outcome.

One arm snatch x 4 each arm
Pull-up x 2
5 Rounds

One arm bench press x 6 each arm
Asymmetrical back lunge x 6 each leg
3 Rounds

One arm snatch x 4 each arm
Pull-up x 2
5 Rounds

#performanceredefined #beactive #hotelexercise #hyattfitness #physicalliteracy #makeexercisematter #knowyourwhy #iaffwfi #iaffpeerfitness #5minutesoffun #fittothrive

Recent Blog Posts

  • Build a growth mindset to be active for life!
  • The pros and cons of CrossFit…

Recent Articles

  • Keys to implementing healthy workplace initiatives
  • Firefighter fitness MUST be prioritized beyond the training academy!

Upcoming Courses

  • F2T 110 Fitness Fundamentals (For Active PFTs) June 22, 2023. Registration closes June 20th! NOTE – There...
    Read More
  • F2T 101 Fitness Principles (Virtual) September 25 – October 31, 2023 Register Now!!
  • F2T 110 Fitness Fundamentals (For Legacy PFTs) June 22, 2023. Registration closes June 20th! NOTE – There...
    Read More

© 2022 - Performance Redefined

  • Home
  • About
  • Workshops